March 13, 2012

History should be treated with truth-loving respect...

I was looking through old posts, and thought this one worth re-posting. Just for my own satisfaction; no one else is likely to care. From November 26, 2001...

British attack in  the film Barry LyndonThe Captain [i.e. Steven den Beste, much missed in the Blogosphere] has written a great bit debunking the persistent myth that the American colonists fought the British by shooting from behind trees and rocks, while the redcoats foolishly paraded in lines.

This is a tall tale that never dies, but in fact the linear tactics were used by both sides for good reasons.

The smoothbore muskets used then were very inaccurate. An individual sniper would be unlikely to do much damage. (Even at Lexington and Concord, the majority of the British survived that long cruel day.) Only with masses of men firing in volleys was firepower effective. AND, muskets were slow to reload. While you were reloading, your only defense was the bayonet. Again, the individual was vulnerable, but a line of men could present a bristling front of bayonets.

Some colonists had rifles, which were very accurate. BUT, rifles then were VERY slow to load, and didn't have bayonets. They were a grief to the British, but never decisive in battle.

Just as important, no one back then had figured out how to control a battle when men were crawling about taking cover. It was a then-insuperable problem. (It was really only solved in 1918, when the Ludendorf Offensives almost defeated the Allies)

I have read that Baron von Steuben, who taught infantry tactics to Washington's army, was flagrantly homosexual. I don't know the details, but gays might want to keep him in mind.

Also good to remember is that the British at Lexington were peace-time soldiers who had never practiced their craft seriously; and didn't expect to find themselves at war (their position was similar to modern "peacekeeping missions".) If the same battle were fought a year later, they would have burned Lexington and Concord to the ground, and massacred any Minutemen who couldn't run very very fast.

I would add that the British at the time of Lexington had the tactics to deal with the colonial rabble. But they hadn't practiced, and were simply not ready. Every battalion (maybe 800 men in 10 companies) had a "light company." These were supposed to be agile and intelligent chaps who could move ahead of the line, dealing with enemy skirmishers and irregulars. They should have given the colonists some real difficulties, but didn't.

The famous British Rifle Regiments emerged from the Revolutionary War. They were fast-moving units clothed in dark green, with black details. They carried no flags, because they did not form a line. Bugles were used for rapid signaling. They marched twice as fast as the ponderous redcoats, and prided themselves on self-discipline and initiative. In a Rifle Regiment—they still exist—"red" is an insult! But it has nothing to do with Communism.

The French await British attack in  the film Barry Lyndon

The pictures are from Kubrick's film Barry Lyndon, set in the Seven Years War. It is very good as a historical picture—give it a try. Some of the scenes were filmed by candle-light, which was astonishing at the time, 1975. I will never forget my frustration when I went to see it, and as the British attacked in line (the picture at the top) some guy loudly said, "I never understood this!" I could have explained it to him, but alas it was not possible. The lower picture is of the French unit bracing for that oncoming British attack. White was the pre-Revolutionary French color.

Just as a crazy extra for you, the Seven Years War was actually started in America. It was started, in fact, by a colonial officer. A certain young Colonel George Washington, whose rash and bloodthirsty attack on Frenchmen who were not at war with the British, ignited a conflagration that might well be called "the first world war." Fun facts for you. Only available at RJ.

Posted by John Weidner at March 13, 2012 7:51 PM

Which reminds me of "Conquered into Liberty" by Eliot Cohen; of which there is good review by Joel Schwartz in a recent issue of Weekly Standard.

Posted by: Rich Magner at March 18, 2012 1:54 PM


Posted by: matt at October 17, 2014 12:24 PM

What do you do for a living? ">cost albendazole VOD also provides a fresh revenue stream for networks. Unlike viewers using digital video recorders, those watching shows on video or demand often can't fast forward through commercials. Research firm Rentrak estimates the VOD ad market totals about $1 billion year. Total TV ad revenue reached $62.5 billion in 2012, according to media buying firm MagnaGlobal.

Posted by: Jada at October 20, 2014 8:40 PM

I can't get a signal ">buy amoxicillin over the counter uk But Wood's story is rare. The list of her promising Britishpeers to have been bought out by established U.S. companiesmakes depressing reading for Cameron's team. Internet radiostation sold to CSB in 2007, while games firm Playfishwas bought by Electronic Arts for about $300 million in2009. TweetDeck, a desktop for managing social media, wassnapped up by Twitter in 2011 and Summly, an app founded by17-year old Nick D'Aloisio, sold out to Yahoo for a rumoured $30million in March, only months after it launched.

Posted by: Zoe at October 20, 2014 8:40 PM

I've lost my bank card ">Generic Acticin The Pediatrics study suggests the pediatricians, who should already be urging children to move more and eat better, might tailor their messages differently so that kids' healthy behaviors improve across the board. For boys, whose gains in physical activity have come with an increase in video gaming, physicians might praise the exercise and caution against screen time. For girls, who are eating more fruits and vegetables but acknowledge they still eat lots of sweets, they might focus on the health costs of added sugar.

Posted by: Isaac at October 20, 2014 8:41 PM

I want to make a withdrawal ">Buy Acticin Online Investigating a 2010 oil spill at Marshall in Michigan, whenalmost 850,000 gallons of crude was discharged into a wetlandfrom a broken pipeline, the NTSB found similar failures made theincident far worse. The spill was not detected or addressed forover 17 hours, during which time control room staff repeatedlyignored alarms and tried to restart the pipeline twice.

Posted by: Genesis at October 20, 2014 8:41 PM

A pension scheme ">purchase cheap bimatoprost The measures have already cut Iran's oil exports by more than half compared to pre-sanctions levels of about 2.2 million barrels per day, helping to devalue Iran's currency and contributing to a steep rise in inflation.

Posted by: Alexander at October 21, 2014 7:22 AM

Could I have , please? ">Generic Atrovent Just call it an achy breaky breakup: The parents of Miley Cyrus are ending their marriage. Tish Cyrus has filed for divorce from her country singer husband Billy Ray Cyrus in Los Angeles Superior Court citing "irreconcilable differences," TMZ reports. "This is a personal matter and we are working to find a resolution that is in the best interest of our family. We ask that you respect our privacy at this time," Tish told People Magazine in a statement. It's a road this couple has been down once before. In 2010, Billy Ray filed for divorce but later changed his mind.

Posted by: Jada at October 21, 2014 4:16 PM

How much were you paid in your last job? ">best where to buy albendazole in garden grove ca laden "We are deeply concerned by the escalation in violence between government security forces and members of the opposition party Renamo," said U.S. State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf. "We are encouraging the two parties to take visible and decisive steps to de-escalate the current tense environment."

Posted by: freelove at October 21, 2014 9:13 PM

This is your employment contract ">thirteen mountain albendazole online purchase thoughtfully joy Providence, Rhode Island, was held up as a city that is making its way back to fiscal stability after loss of population and industry had put it on the brink of bankruptcy. A shared sacrifice approach that included spending cuts and tax increases led the city toward recovery, the center's report said.

Posted by: Xavier at October 21, 2014 9:14 PM

Could I have a statement, please? ">oysters order albendazole online worth Since 1980, the debt ceiling has been raised 39 times. It was raised 17 times under Ronald Reagan, four times under Bill Clinton and seven times under George W. Bush. Congress is currently in a contentious debate with the White House on whether to raise the ceiling again by mid-October, which would be the sixth increase under Barack Obama. Bars indicate the debt each month of the year.

Posted by: Chloe at October 21, 2014 9:14 PM

I'm unemployed order diflucan mail In nearly a dozen incidents over the last decade that take the term “cyber-stalking” to a whole new level, NSA employees broke NSA rules to enter phone numbers or email addresses associated with their romantic interests, in one case an ex, into vast databases to see to whom they were talking, according to the agency’s Inspector General.

Posted by: Patrick at October 22, 2014 2:43 AM

Lost credit card 150 mg diflucan Sift the flour and a pinch of salt into a mixing bowl, then stir in the 25 grams of sugar and make a well in the centre. Pour in the beaten eggs and add a little of the milk. With a wooden spoon, start to beat and gradually add more milk until you have a smooth batter that drops reluctantly off the spoon. Stir in the brown butter.

Posted by: Arianna at October 22, 2014 2:44 AM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Weblog by John Weidner