February 27, 2007
But life is short, and things do matter....
It's one of those days—weeks—when the third cuppa joe does not steam any bloggable fumes up from the depths of the tired brain. And anyway, I saw this quote from a piece by Mark Helprin at Peter Burnet's blog, and and it's too good to even add a comment to....
...One seldom encounters pure nihilism, for just as anarchists are usually very well-organized, most of what passes for nihilism is a compromise with advocacy. Present literary forms may spurn the individual, emotion, beauty, sacrifice, love, and truth, but they energetically embrace the collective, coldness of feeling, ugliness, self-assertion, contempt, and disbelief. And why? Simply because the acolytes of modernism are terribly and justly afraid. They fear that if they do not display their cynicism they will be taken for fools. They fear that if they commit to and uphold something outside the puppet channels of orthodoxy they will be mocked, that if they are open they will be attacked, that if they appreciate that which is simple and good they will foolishly have overlooked its occult corruptions, that if they stand they will be struck down, that if they love they will lose, and that if they live they will die.Posted by John Weidner at February 27, 2007 07:35 AM
As surely they will. And others of their fears are legitimate as well, so they withdraw from engagement and risk into what they believe is the safety of cynicism and mockery. The sum of their engagement is to show that they are disengaged, and they have built an elaborate edifice, which now casts a shadow over every facet of civilization, for the purpose of representing their cowardice as wisdom. Mainly to protect themselves, they write coldly, cruelly, and as if nothing matters.
But life is short, and things do matter, often more than the human heart can bear. This is an elemental truth that neither temporarily victorious nihilism, nor fashion, nor cowardice can long suppress, which is why the literary tenor of the times cannot and will not last. And which is one reason among many why one must not accept its dictates or write according to its conventions. These must and will fall, for they are subject to constant pressure as generation after generation rises in unprompted affirmation of human nature. And though perhaps none living may see the change, it is an honor to predict and await it.
When can we see the Death and deconstruction of nihilism? This system of non-belief that says like a spoiled child..."The world is not perfect and doesn't meet my expectations, so it's not worth having/living/loving/defending." Grow up and get a job.
Posted by: doug in colorado at February 27, 2007 02:26 PMHow do you deconstruct "nothing?" How do you kill nothing? There's nothing to fight.
You say "grow up." That's exactly it, I suspect. A child has no demands placed on him. If you believe in something, that thing makes demands on you, and so is, in effect, asking you to grow up. We have a plague of Peter Panism.
Where does nothing come from? It seems to soak through the fabric of humanity like some penetratring dye. Suddenly nothing is there...
Newman predicted all this, by the way. Our world is just a working-out of what he expected to happen.
And in my humblest of spheres here, I've been forced to see the same, because I've been trying since 11/2001 to come to grips in debate with "them," and there's nothing there.
Posted by: John Weidner at February 27, 2007 04:32 PMWell Put! And I'm a long time fan of your blog, keep up the thoughtful and skillful writing.
Doug
Oh...and to a Nihilist...
"Nothing" is sacred. :-)
"Nothing" is sacred
Well said! That's very funny...
