August 21, 2006

The real McCoy...

The Anchoress, on why she will not agree to suggestions she drop her support of Rudy Giuliani, although she disagrees with his positions on social issues like abortion...

....Giuliani showed me who he was ‘way back when he was refusing Yassar Arafat access to NYC, at a time when the whole world was lauding the monster and kissing his backside. He showed who he was when we were attacked and he managed to reassure the whole nation that capable, adult people were in charge. He showed me who he was when he attended scores of funerals, comforted hundreds of families, walked brides down the aisle because their slain fathers and brothers were lost in the WTC rubble. He showed me who he was when he returned a “relief check” for ten million dollars to a Saudi Prince, because the money came with a denunciation of Israel and of the Jews and US Policy. We need this unshakable and intrepid man, who is incapable of dithering, in these times.

We know this man, Giuliani, and he is a man-in-full. I would rather have one faulty, imperfect man-in-full in office, (one who is willing to be unpopular, if that’s what it takes) and dealing with our devils, than a dozen “more perfect and palatable” types who either can’t get elected or are too distracted by the demands of “the base” to do what needs doing.

And so, no…I won’t be withdrawing my support for Rudy Giuliani at this time. I’m not into throwing people away as “lost causes,” simply because they don’t “fall in line,” and who would want someone who does that, anyway?....

I agree. He's the only real man among those running, of either party. It looks like it's going to be a lonnng war, and the last thing we need is some weak sister in the White House. He's wrong on some issues, but has been superbly right on others...

Posted by John Weidner at August 21, 2006 02:34 PM
Comments

Could I be so bold as to suggest that "real men" don't think it's okay that we've killed over 40,000,000 Americans since the first states decriminalized abortion in 1967? Or that "real men" don't think it's okay to kill embryonic human beings to satisfy others' health needs? Or that "real men" don't want to aid in the undermining of society's foundations?

Just a few suggestions from someone who is a man -- although I can't be sure if I'm "real" or not.

Posted by: Nate Nelson at August 21, 2006 07:53 PM

Nate, I can't really argue with that at all--you are right.

It's the same problem I have with Tony Blair. He towers above other world leaders as a war leader, but his socialist policies are hastening the destruction of his people.

It's a quandry. Makes me appreciate Bush all the more...

Posted by: John Weidner at August 22, 2006 06:03 AM

Nate - if Rudy held your same fundamental understanding of what abortion is and what it means, and still neglected to do something about it, then yes, he wouldn't be a "real man" (since that's the term we've been using here). But if someone looks at it, sees a medical proceedure or a contraception analog, and then proceeds to treat it as such - I don't think that speaks to his manhood one way or another. It may speak to his judgement, but not to his courage, persistance, spirit, leadership, perseverence, strength - his manhood.

Posted by: Ethan Hahn at August 22, 2006 07:22 AM
Weblog by John Weidner