July 30, 2006

Book recommendation

Both Charlene and I highly recommend the book 1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus, which is about the populations and civilizations of the Western Hemisphere before Europeans arrived. It pulls together a large amount of research that has been done in recent decades. In short, everything you thought you knew (or at least, that we thought we knew) about the indians is wrong.

There were many more indians (the author, by the way, makes it quite clear that "indians" is the preferred term, not PC constructions like "Native American") than historians had realized, the hemisphere was much more "civilized" and more modified by human action than anyone had guessed.

And the diseases that explorers brought were much more lethal than historians had thought. (Why more lethal? Probably mostly because the indian populations were much less genetically diverse, having grown from rather small populations that migrated from Asia. Also because they did not live in proximity to domestic animals, which have been a source of many of our disease organisms.) Epidemics spread in waves ahead of Europeans, and only the very earliest explorers saw intact populations. And their reports were often dismissed as lies by those who came a few years later, and found a very different situation.

For instance, the vile Hernando de Soto wandered through our Southeastern states and reported them thickly populated with towns, often three others being visible from any one. A century later, de la Salle passed through some of the same places without seeing a village for hundreds of miles! And the earliest Europeans did not find millions of Buffalo. That was a population explosion that resulted from the collapse of human populations.

I found the section on the Amazon Basin the most staggering. It too was thickly populated...

...[p. 284] Carvajal wrote little about the peoples who spent so much time trying to kill him. But the small amount he did write depicts a crowded and prosperous land. Approaching what is now the Peru-Brazil border, he noted that, "the farther we went, the more thickly populated and the better did we find the land." One 180-mile stretch was "all inhabited, for there was not from village to village a crossbow shot."

How did the people live? By planting trees. The Amazonian forest today is amazingly thick with fruit and nut-bearing trees, and many researchers now believe that these are in fact the remnants of old "orchards." Also, they found the means to enrich the soil--jungle soil is notoriously poor, but perhaps as much as 10% of the Amazon Basin has rich black soil that can grow crops for decades without fertilizers. People dig it up and sell it as potting soil. How did they do it? Hey, read the book! You will be so astonished.

Posted by John Weidner at July 30, 2006 07:57 AM
Comments

I've heard about the terra negra ("black earth") of the Amazon. There was an article in Discovery or something -- it was a while back. There are bacteria, I think, that actually make the soil grow. I think I will add this book to my Amazon list.

Posted by: Andrea Harris at July 30, 2006 11:05 AM

Oops, it's actually "terra preta." My Portuguese isn't so good.

Posted by: Andrea Harris at July 30, 2006 11:12 AM

The terra preta stuff just knocks me out. It is such an alternative to the usual PC eco-dogma, about how the Amazon forest (and the whole planet as well) is doooomed unless it remains the home of only a few raggedy-assed tribes with blow-guns. (Or better yet, no horrid humans at all.)

E-mail me your address. Charlene and I would enjoy sending you a copy.

Posted by: John Weidner at July 30, 2006 01:42 PM

Done! I sent it from my gmail account. Thanks!

Posted by: Andrea Harris at July 30, 2006 08:32 PM

Yeah, what Europeans and Asians got spread over 2000 years of plagues and disaster the native Americans got in about 100 years. It utterly destroyed them...

In fact, it would have destroyed them even if the Native Americans (I don’t like confusing them with the peoples of the subcontinent) had been the ones to reach Europe (or China). No matter when contact was made, it was going to destroy the population...

Did you read Guns Germs and Steel? Your summary is basically Mr. Diamond’s thesis...

Posted by: Andrew Cory at August 2, 2006 10:10 PM

Contact was inevitably going to destroy the Indians. Perhaps that's why the stupefying numbers of deaths do not horrify me as much as the various genocides of our own times. Or perhaps it's just too big for my imagination to grasp.

But what really interests me personally here is that so much of what we have been taught about our hemisphere is simply wrong. Edifices of thought have been built on the idea of small numbers of Indians, living "in harmony with nature," whilst Buffalo and Passenger Pigeons flourished in their millions...

So, can we adjust? Can we re-think? Re-write the textbooks? I predict, no. Rather, as those who hold the old views die or retire, younger people will replace their views with newer ones. This rigidity utterly fascinates me.

(What I have heard of Diamond has made we unwilling to waste time reading him. Perhaps I'm wrong, but I have piles of books on flat surfaces all over the house waiting to be read.)

Posted by: John Weidner at August 3, 2006 06:21 AM
Weblog by John Weidner