April 01, 2006

The raft of state...

From an article bout Secretary of State Rice's trip to England, 'Tactical Errors' Made In Iraq, Rice Concedes:

...But in response to a question about whether the administration had learned from its mistakes over the past three years, she said officials would be "brain-dead" if they did not recognize where they had erred.

"I know we've made tactical errors, thousands of them I'm sure," Rice said. "But when you look back in history, what will be judged is, did you make the right strategic decisions."...

This is so right, so smart, that it makes my head spin to think that brain-dead lefties will probably seize on it as an admission of something being wrong.

  • Every big difficult undertaking will involve lots of mistakes.
  • Every war America has ever fought started with lots of mistakes.
  • Doing anything in this new millennium is likely to include mistakes, because we are all of us groping our way through a trackless and shifting landscape.
  • In almost anything you attempt, it is better to get the strategic decisions right, as opposed to the tactical ones. A drunk weaving his way down the right street to get home is better off than an intrepid hiker taking the wrong street.
  • In the long run, those who leap into problems and experiment and learn from failures are going to get farther than those masterminds who devise perfect plans to avoid all mistakes. To borrow a metaphor, the first group is like a raft that moves slowly and unglamorously. The second is like a ship that moves with speed. Until it hits a rock. Then it sinks.
Posted by John Weidner at April 1, 2006 01:56 PM
Comments

There is an old military saying: "No plan suvives first contact with the enemy fully intact."

Posted by: John Lanning at April 2, 2006 10:14 AM

Too right. And we should ALL of us be thinking like that. We are all being swept into the future, and the rate of change is only going to increase.

All of our plans are likely to suddenly fall apart. We need to be ready to improvise in the midst of chaos. (I'm not saying I am, but at least I have the concept!)

Were/are you in the Opfor? 11th ACR? The whole concept of training using a dedicated "opposition force" just fascinates me.

Posted by: John Weidner at April 2, 2006 11:04 AM
Weblog by John Weidner