March 17, 2006

Most conservative President since Nixon...

Orrin Judd gives us some numbers to keep in mind, while discussing this article, Hey, Big Spender Should we have known that President Bush would bust the budget? by Peggy Noonan...

....At any rate, given that Ms Noonan believes, for some reason, that Ronald Reagan was a conservative and George W. Bush isn't, it's perhaps helpful to just compare the two: when Ronald Reagan left office in 1988 he was dunning us 18.1% of GDP to pay for a federal government that spent 21.2% of GDP. In 2004, the last year for which I could find numbers, George W. Bush had lowered our tax burden to 16.3% of GDP-- a level last reached in 1959--to pay for a government that spent 19.8 of GDP.

There doesn't seem to be any coherent reason why a president's conservatism should be judged by how much he spends, but if you're using that as your yardstick then Mr. Reagan was the most liberal president since FDR during WWII and George W. Bush and Bill Clinton are the most conservative since Nixon....

I love Peggy, but she's SO Industrial Age.

Posted by John Weidner at March 17, 2006 08:04 AM
Comments

On the Hill in the '80s we had a name for the program advocated by PN: root canal policy. RR instinctively avoided it and went for the high road to the delight of the country and the discomfort of the old guard on the Hill. The gripe with Bush2 is nouveau old guard and hard to understand from PN.

Posted by: Luciferous at March 17, 2006 01:10 PM

Ronnie Reagan is dead and Peggy Noonan isn't his speechwriter anymore. That's Noonan's issue and she just won't give it up.

Posted by: Xixi at March 18, 2006 08:06 PM
Weblog by John Weidner