January 07, 2006
Bring 'em on...
There's another lie going around, about how the Bush Administration is responsible for the recent coal miner deaths.
Newsbusters has the facts; a general downturn in deaths since 1995. (With an uptick in the last Clinton years, which I'm sure the media found perfectly acceptable.) And compare 2005's 22 American deaths with China's 2,600!
But what bothers me more then the political gotcha games, is the picture I've seen presented recently of miners as poor ignorant fools driven to unacceptable work by greedy capitalism. This is a despicable canard; our miners are well-paid, and are proud to follow a difficult and dangerous craft that is vital to our country. This is exactly the same dirty lie leftists use to dishonor and denigrate our military.
And more bothersome than that, is the sub-text that being a coal miner (or lineman, lumberjack, carpenter, fireman) is to be less important, less significant, less worthy of consideration than being, say, journalists, professors, or clergy. Just the opposite is true. If we tossed out all our journalists, all our professors, and all the fake-Christian lefty-trendoid Jesus-was-a-socialist churchmen, the country would not only be the better for getting rid of rotten ideas, but also better because those people would quickly be replaced by better ones from out of the vast reserves of talent and energy to be found among ordinary Americans.
And more bothersome yet is the subtext that the most important goal of life is safety and security. I won't explain why this is a pernicious thought---if you don't get it already, you probably never will.
Posted by John Weidner at January 7, 2006 09:11 AMWell, its certainly no more stupid than the "Jesus would be a Republican" crap from the right-wing!
Did Bush cause the cave-in? Of course not! And the company that owns the mine (while deserving of scorn for holding back news that the miners were really dead for over 2hrs, even though they knew the families had been told they were alive) have only owned it for 6 weeks, so they don't deserve any attack for the mine's safety record.
That said - this mine has been cited in the last year for over 240 safety violations, which is almost five times the average. And since Bush placed ex-mine company executives and lobbyists in charge of the MHSA, there have in fact been less inspections (and ALL inspections require that the mine get 24hrs notice that they're coming!!!), less citations, and ever decreasing fines for violations. In fact, I've read the total of the fines for the 240+ violations last year by the mine totalled less than $4,000.
Compared to making repairs or maintenance that likely cost over $100,000, is it any wonder most violations become repeat violations?
And hopefully there will be a really complete investigation to see to what degree cited safety violations may have played a role in the accident.
You forgot us dumb farmers and ranchers in "what's the matter" with Kansas.
Posted by: bman at January 13, 2006 09:52 AM
