November 27, 2005
Words of hope on the Internet Railroad...
Tienchi Liao writes in the NY Daily News W's message will inspire millions of Chinese thanks to an Internet underground railroad,
...The police indeed had a stressful time, because they needed as many helping hands as possible in order to produce a pleasant atmosphere in Beijing for President Bush and First Lady Laura Bush. All disturbing elements had to be eliminated before the arrival of the guests. The protesters, the dissidents and the active members of the democratic movement had to be kept either under house arrest or sent out of town. The renowned dissident writer Liu Xiaobo saw his connections to the outside world cut off before and after Bush's visit. He had no phone connection and no Internet access until the presidential couple had left the capital. However, Liu did not begrudge the U.S. President these inconveniences. "No, I do not complain; I am thankful that President Bush visited China," said Liu. "He urged the Chinese leaders to grant more freedom to the Chinese people in his Kyoto speech. He went to a church in Beijing. Bush has not abandoned us, even though the authoritarian regime greeted him with 150 Boeing contracts."
Bush's visit has prompted, in some small way, freedom of speech for the Chinese. The President's remarks encouraging human rights have been disseminated to students and others by the country's intellectuals, who are able to bypass the government's Internet blocks. These leaders, among the 80 million to 100 million Web users, are tapping into the U.S. State Department's site to pass along Bush's remarks urging freedom and democracy.
Neither China's elite nor its common people care how many billions of dollars in contracts have been signed by the two countries. They now know that George Bush has spoken on behalf of their rights and their views. They are not angry that they suffered a temporary loss of freedom because of Bush's visit. They hope to gain lasting freedom, which Bush has pleaded for on their behalf.
I suspect that we will look back on this time much as we look back now at another much-hated cowboy, Ronald Reagan, and remember how his words and actions helped end the Evil Empire.
But words alone can't accomplish anything important. Anyone can demand human rights for some oppressed group, but so what? Who's likely to listen? Reagan earned the right to be heard by using his political capital to rebuild our military, to start SDI, to deploy Pershing missiles in Europe, to bomb Libya. Each of these was the result of a bitter messy political brawl, in which Reagan held firm, and won. They were bellicose actions that led to peaceful change.
Today, President Bush has earned the right to speak for people oppressed under communist regimes. Earned it by standing firm for freedom despite the attacks of terrorists and their leftist allies...
And the possibility of peaceful change is now much greater due to the credibility we have earned. If the "pacifists" and peaceniks were not politicized frauds, they would laud these possibilities and not try to undercut them.
Posted by John Weidner at November 27, 2005 08:30 AMAn excellent use of the bully pulpit.
But credibility? I think not. Bubble Boy has squandered a great deal of our moral capital by his reckless imperial adventure. He is a midget standing on the shoulders of giants.
But even a moral midget in the White House can do a lot of good with well-chosen words, and his words in China stand definitely count as a mark on the plus side of the ledger.
Posted by: Dave Trowbridge at November 29, 2005 08:13 PMIf Bush doesn't have credibility, then he does NOT have a bully pulpit, and his words won't have any effect at all. He might as well be a Jimmy Carter.
But I think you are confusing credibility with popularity. Nobody, even if they hate Bush and everything he's done, can ignore him on the grounds that he never means what he says, or that he is afraid to act.
Bill Clinton used to threaten to attack Iraq and end the threat of WMD's, but nobody got excited because they knew he didn't mean it. That's "lack of credibility."
I have no doubt that the Chinese leaders are taking anything Bush says very seriously. Credibility.
And also, because he handled the incident of the downed spy plane that landed in China with quiet but firm diplomacy and soft language, and even a mild apology, they won't be in much danger of believing those cartoonish views of the President as a reckless cowboy.
(And that 'ol Reckless Adventure has its THIRD election coming up in a few days, and about 100 Iraqi battalions able to fight. The Bully Pulpit definitely works better when you WIN your reckless adventures.)
Posted by: John Weidner at November 29, 2005 09:41 PM
